Go back iconCase Studies

EXALT Switches to Yotpo Self-Service For Reviews, Loyalty, & SMS

collection of EXALT health and fitness beverages
Food icon Food
Platform Shopify
Location UK
Loyalty & Referrals
Visual UGC
Average star rating
0 %
Review conversion rate
0 %
Of repeat buyers are loyalty redeemers
0 x
ROI with Yotpo SMSBump


EXALT co-Founders Charlie and Dan Wilson-Vaughan created their tasty, nutritious protein shakes and juices with sustainability in mind. Packaging with recycled goods and planting one tree per order, EXALT ensures their products are good for shoppers and the planet.


Main Takeaways
EXALT previously used Trustpilot for their review collection, but the brand experienced a lack of customization and ease-of-use.
Wanting to boost retention, EXALT started looking for a loyalty program backed by experts that could help them make it uniquely theirs.
Their next challenge was finding a unique way to engage their loyal customers that worked seamlessly with their existing tech stack.

EXALT’s journey started when they re-platformed to the newest Shopify Online Store 2.0 theme and subsequently hit a wall with their current reviews provider, Trustpilot. They needed a review solution fully compatible with Shopify's new theme and capable of integrating with their other marketing tools.

EXALT beverage with natural ingredients

Because Trustpilot automatically publishes all reviews to trustpilot.com, EXALT didn’t have a grace period to comment on reviews and provide their signature customer service.

EXALT knew reviews would drive customer acquisition rates and establish brand trust. They also knew having a loyalty program would retain the new shoppers they worked to acquire. The brand initially started with different plug-ins and pop-ups before realizing they needed a more robust, customizable loyalty solution to fulfill their customers’ needs.

On top of searching for reviews and loyalty solutions that support a unified customer journey, EXALT also needed new ways to engage their customers outside of traditional emails. Originally using their ESP’s built-in SMS capabilities, they noticed some notable shortcomings when setting timelines for campaign automations, subscriber collection tools, and overall cross-product interactions.

Photo of Charlie Wilson-Vaughan, Co-Founder of EXALT

”No matter your company size, Yotpo ticks all the boxes, providing hands-on, dedicated support during each stage of onboarding. And they have an easy-to-use platform.”

EXALT logo Charlie Wilson-Vaughan, Co-Founder


Main Takeaways
Yotpo Reviews allow for private and public commenting, which enhance EXALT’s level of customer service and brand reputation.
With Yotpo Loyalty, EXALT built an on-brand, integrated rewards page without any coding.
Yotpo SMSBump opens EXALT up to new ways of engaging with their customers and increases their referral submission.

A new and growing brand, EXALT found the right plan for their business size and challenges with Yotpo’s self-service plans: Reviews Prime, Loyalty Gold, and SMS Growth.

With Yotpo’s advanced review moderation, EXALT can answer customer issues directly and provide hands-on one-on-one customer support. Gone are the days of automatic review publishing with no customer service oversight. Charlie and Dan directly rectify any grievances themselves, making their shoppers feel seen and often converting what could have been unhappy customers into dedicated, loyal ones.

“Many of our Yotpo reviews mention us [as] ‘the boys’ and rave about our wonderful customer service model that Yotpo has enabled us to create, “ says Charlie.

When it came to EXALT's more posh customers, simply offering a discount coupon wasn't enough to prompt a purchase. By offering generous rewards to loyalty members, EXALT dramatically increases their positive sentiment and retention among customers.

“10% of sales goes back into loyalty rewards. We wanted to be generous with our customers to show them how much we care,” says Charlie. EXALT capitalized on product synergies when they built out their rewards program and rewarded customers for writing a review, uploading a photo or video review, and signing up for SMS.

Charlie and Dan were initially hesitant to embrace SMS marketing, as they worried that sending too many marketing messages across channels might overwhelm customers. But, after some in-depth research and comparing open rates between SMS and email, they knew SMS was the right choice for the brand.

“We do whatever Yotpo recommends because of [their] expertise in the industry and D2C as a whole, so when it was time to switch to Yotpo SMS, it was a no-brainer,” says Charlie. To maximize retention, EXALT uses the Post-Purchase Sign-Up feature to turn new shoppers into SMS subscribers. They also send SMS reminders for photo sharing and reward balances to keep shoppers engaged throughout the buying cycle.

EXALT loyalty points example

”Regardless of your business size, Yotpo is able to take what could be three completely different fragmented solutions, and bundle them under one comprehensive and integrated tech stack.”

EXALT logo Charlie Wilson-Vaughan, Co-Founder


Main Takeaways
EXALT boasts a 4.87 average star rating with a 6% review conversion rate.
60% of their repeat purchasers are loyalty redeemers.
EXALT’s SMS strategy drives 38.7x ROI.

Switching from Trustpilot to Yotpo’s platform approach has brought EXALT’s customer journey full circle: from acquisition to retention and engagement.

Yotpo’s Google Ads and SEO optimization features allow shoppers to see what other customers are saying about EXALT’s products, including rich snippets and their noteworthy 4.87 average star rating. By choosing a Google certified partner, EXALT is now able to improve organic traffic and engagement, boosting acquisition from new customers with enhanced search results.

Retention is also a major concern for most brands, but not for EXALT. Their product quality, hands-on customer support via review commenting, and effective loyalty strategy are reflected in their retention rate. On average, a D2C brand’s retention rate sits around 20% to 30%, while EXALT’s is around 85%. In addition, 60% of their repeat purchasers are loyalty redeemers, demonstrating how appropriately rewarding shoppers reduces churn and turns first-time shoppers into avid brand loyalists.

Engaging with your customer at the right time in the right way is vital, and Yotpo SMSBump empowers EXALT to do just that. Driving 39x ROI with customized SMS flows, EXALT is excited to keep building their SMS strategy and continuing to make those personal connections with their shoppers.

Photo of Charlie Wilson-Vaughan, Co-Founder of EXALT

”Retention in our industry sits around 20-30%. Ours is 85%. Once our customers give it a go, they are hooked. The level of customer service and rewards we provide is a huge factor.”

EXALT logo Charlie Wilson-Vaughan, Co-Founder

Recent Case Studies

Interested in Yotpo?
Schedule a call with one of our eCommerce experts to learn more.
Thank you.
We'll be in touch in no time! In the meantime, take a look at what our customers are saying about Yotpo.
Yotpo customers logosYotpo customers logosYotpo customers logos
Laura Doonin, Commercial Director recommendation on yotpo

“Yotpo is a fundamental part of our recommended tech stack.”

Shopify plus logo Laura Doonin, Commercial Director
Yotpo customers logosYotpo customers logosYotpo customers logos